Tag Archives: David Loy

A Conversation with Buddhist Leaders on Climate Change

It is a transcendence of ego, not the planet, that is needed. We don’t need to let go of our beautiful earth and the many species living with us, but let go of our ego and the ways we think we need to live, and what we think we need to have. Santacitta Bhikkhuni

When I first envisaged the series Mindfulness / Dharma and Climate Action, my primary intention was twofold. First it is important for Dharma teachers to set an example by speaking out about climate emergency. Second, I hoped all of us would be inspired to take the conversation into our local communities and sanghas however challenging that may be. What I didn’t expect was how moving it was to hear each of the teachers communicate such a deep sense of concern with intelligence, compassion and urgency. Through the five conversations with the input of 16 teachers, many topics were touched into which gives us a “library” to continue to draw from. During our last call of the series on Sunday, Ayya Santussika and Ayya Santacitta really brought home the urgency of our situation, while David Loy gave us a very clear template for placing and managing the dire nature of our times. You can hear the whole conversation here.

Seth Levinson We were sorry that Bhikkhu Bodhi could not join us due to a health issue that morning. However, I really can’t emphasis enough his extraordinary leadership in Buddhist engagement in social justice and climate emergency issues.

Bhikkhu Bodhi is a guiding star. Please do check out B.Bodhi’s writing and also Buddhist Global Relief which he initiated and which is an amazing organization supporting people across the world who are marginalized and struggling with few resources.

David Loy – “The Bodhisattva Path – A perfect template for our times.”

David called on us to re-examine our own tradition of Buddhism in the light of the climate crisis, reflecting how difficult it has been to date to bring about a more progressive response to environmental concerns. He mentioned that a book he and John David-Loy-175Stanley co-edited “A Buddhist Response to Climate Emergency” had been mostly ignored. Going deeper, David talked of an ambiguity at the foundations of our tradition, which really needs to be addressed. That due to the idea of transcendence, nibbana (peace) becomes a goal that is understood as indifference to the world; so rather than engage the world we check out. He then went on to say that a primary perspective of Westernized Buddhism has been its fruitful interaction with psychology and psychotherapy. That while there has been much good that has come of that, it tends to encourage the idea that “my” problems are in my own head, and if I work on that level then the basic problems of my life will be solved.

David pointed out that the danger of both approaches discourages the kind of engagement with the world that we really now need. We also need to understand that in reality our experience of the world is the ways we construct it due to our dualistic understanding that makes us feel separate. Deconstructing a dualistic relationship with the world also needs to be done, not only personally, but also collectively, on a social level — that when we talk of dukkha (suffering) we are not only talking about individual dukkha, but also on an institutionalized level.

David finished by pointing out that within Buddhist tradition we have an archetype that speaks directly to what we now need. This is the Bodhisattva Path. Rather than view this in the usual sectarian way, we need to rise about that and realize it offers a particular orientation that addresses the situation we find ourselves in now. What is so special about the bodhisattva focus is it offers a double practice that is actually two sides of the same path. One is our inner practice and the other is outer engagement. It is not enough to settle for inner peace, there is also a need to respond to a suffering world. In finding this balance, while being called on to do the very best we can, not knowing if it will make a difference, we can also practice inwardly. As we begin to wake up and realize we are not separate from the world we move into the bodhisattva path – which involves pretty big vows. While it’s easy to feel overwhelmed, what makes it possible is returning to a place of equanimity or emptiness. This is beautifully articulated in the teaching of Nisagardatta Maharaj, Wisdom says “I am nothing” while compassion says “I am everything” between these two banks, the life of the practitioner flows.

Ayya Santussika Bhikkhuni – “We are the first generation to feel the impact of climate change and the last generation that can do something about it.”

Ayya Santussika said she wanted to reflect on what kind of actions can we take as bodhisattvas, putting our bodies, hearts and minds into action. Ayya said her primary focus was on building a Buddhist movement. Why do we need a movement? ayya_santussika-175Because our leaders have lost their moral compass. On a corporate level if they were truthful regards the impact of their products — which is the kind of ethical stance we need to make sure our environment and biosphere is healthy — then we wouldn’t need a movement.

Who is it that is meant to ensure that business acts ethically? Ayya said she doesn’t like to say corporations have power; it is the people running corporations that have power. Every decision we make creates karma. If we really understand that and take that in, then we really don’t want to have any investments in fossil fuels, we don’t want to encourage the use of fossil fuels, we want to move away from them as quickly as possible – even though we still have to use them at the moment because we don’t have sufficient alternatives, we what to mobilize those alternatives as rapidly as possible. What we want is governments that protect the people rather than exploit them – governments that keep business in check when its lost its moral compass.

However government has lost its moral compass. So when that happens the people have to get together to make their voices heard. We have to rise up! When hundreds of thousands of people demand ethical leadership, then things start to change.  Ayya went onto say that right now we are dealing with a lot of misinformation. The idea that governments are doing what they can about climate change is erroneous. If so they would ban fracking and the extreme extraction of fossil fuels. As this is not happening, we have to get involved.

Ayya Santussika then went on to lay out a number of ways we can be involved:

  1. Reach out to other Buddhists on a national/ international level – connect with each other – inspire each other, be ready to mobilize for mass mobilization when needed. (Please contact Ayya directly to sign up for more info: santussika@gmail.com)
  2. Join together with other people of faith such as Our Voices, an initiative of Green Faith, which is organizing to have millions of people sign on, expressing our love for the earth and our children, for all beings.
  3. Our Voices is aiming to a) Spread awareness about what spiritual & faith groups are doing. b) Help spiritual groups with their own call to action. c) Organize days of prayer and action.

For example December 7th is Light for Lima. Also check out Pledge to Mobilize. When many, many people take actions like this, then those in negotiations are encouraged, inspired and pressured – and that’s what we need to stand up to the billions of dollars in the industry that is furthering the destruction and leading us into disaster and catastrophe.

Abraham Lincoln, in his Gettysburg address talked about; “A government Of the People, By the People, For the People” Now we have a government: Of the Billionaires, By the Billionaires, For the Billionaires! Because of this we need to stand up – to do what we do from a place of practice, of depth, according to the bodhisattva vow – As we do so, to move from a place of connection. It’s a joyful thing to do!

Ayya Santacitta Bhikkhuni – “The people united will never be defeated.” (From a song composed on the Peoples Climate Train)

Ayya Santacitta followed on by encouraging us to act on what is happening – to make a difference. But we have to start where we are. If we have a sense of despair and confusion, we start with that – but the important thing is that we start – We Santacittacan no longer be only with our own experience and stop there, we need to see what holds us back from full heartedly engaging the conversation and stepping out. The world at the moment is holding up a very big mirror to us. The way we are living is no longer sustainable. The worldview we have been living in for a long time is clearly not working. A world view based on fossil fuels – we are dressed, eating, living, transporting ourselves within and by fossil fuels – they are all over our life, every where, every corner. On the other hand we want to stay below 2 degrees warming. For that we can only burn 550 gigatons of fossil fuels – but industry has identified 2800 gigatons – about 5 times more. Already we are in a very dire situation.

Ayya Santacitta, as did Ayya Santussika, emphasized that we need to organize – to pressure our governments to make clear decisions. We don’t have much time left and we have already gone too far. Making the transitions needed is going to be difficult – we can’t assume this is easy – but we need to wake up to the fact that if we don’t take action its going to be impossible for civilization to continue. It’s simply not going to be possible! Ayya then went on to say that she appreciated contemplating old age, sickness and death of a worldview that no longer serves us – a view that needs to change. To bring this change about we need to demand action from our politicians and support those politicians who are trying to bring about change.

Ayya said if we don’t know what to do, then join with others. She also pointed us back to the Buddha who left a very strong framework, starting with the five precepts. Even if we observed the first two (to refrain from taking life & to not take what is not given), then that would be a powerful impact. Ayya also encouraged us as Buddhists to step out, and make our voices heard. I particularly liked the way Ayya Santacitta picked up on what David said earlier, addressing the distorted understanding of transcendence, which no longer serves. For so long transcendence has been favored, but it is a transcendence of the ego, not of the planet! We have to outgrow the worldview we now have as the planet cannot support it.  Ayya also mentioned Pennie Opal Plant, a 1st Nation elder, who likened those of us “rising up” as the immune system of the planet. Again emphasizing the need to speak out, that even 7 – 10% of the population can make a difference. We can do this (and we can “let go” once we’ve done all we can!)

earth touching mudraAyya finished with the archetype of the Buddha in his Earth Touching Mudra; when hefearless mudra
touched the ground on the moment of his enlightenment, he touched the earth. We belong here and so therefore we have the authority to speak on behalf of the earth. The Buddha also used the Fearlessness Mudra when walking in the world – This perfectly symbolizes the balance of both inner and outer. Ayya finished by saying we must “connect with each other and live the Buddha’s teaching fully.”

The week the world changed by thanissara

Pause and take a moment to realize what a phenomenal and unprecedented happening has occurred across the globe this week in support of immediate climate action. We are witnessing the birth of a people power united across race, geography, faith, class, gender, expunging all other socio-colonial-patriachal defined “isms.”

Climate March in New York

We the people have walked and we now speak for a reality which has been dangerously twisted, distorted, denied and suppressed by the corporate-fossil fuel-oligarchic owned media agenda. This reality is catastrophic climate chaos is upon us, it is real, it is happening, and if we don’t act now, we will destroy the biosphere and render the earth unsustainable for all life. There as no one on the 2,700 marches across the globe, or the 400,000 marchers in New York City that didn’t know this to be true.

London marching
London marching

The march was a statement for political leaders gathering right now to talk our planetary future. Take another moment to watch this stunning opening offering from 26 year old poet Kathy Jetnil-Kijiner, from the Marshall Islands at the UN Secretary-General’s Climate Summit. As world leaders hash it out in the UN Climate Action Summit, we need to acknowledge the true leaders that are among us which is the First Nation Peoples who led our 4 mile long (7+ kilometers) people march through the streets of New York. They know the territory, they understand the disease and they have the remedy.

They have the remedy because they also understand we all have the remedy. We know this when we listen beyond our colonized minds to hear the deep, urgent impulse of sanity that is aligned to the heartbeat of the earth, of the ancestors, of the animals, and of the total web of life. This is the deep feminine primordial mother earth who births all things and who cries out to us now, each of us, to hear her urging. Stand up and be my protector. Do what you can, embody the sacred masculine and be a warrior-lover of the earth, of each other, of our best heart.



So dear friends, our task is before us. We must take the inspiration of this historic moment in the climate movement and bring it into our lives while also speaking out to share the message the best we can. While there is no turning back, it is important to remember we are doing this together.

As a Buddhist practitioner it was especially great to see a strong gathering of cross denominational Buddhists turn up to align forces with People of Faith. The determination I felt on the march from those stepping out alongside me was palpable. We must go forward and work hard to secure our collective future.  As we do so, we will see game changers happening.



Already as the momentum for change is building, results are coming in. Divestments from the fossil fuel industry are happening fast. Yesterday it was announced that Rockefeller’s divested $860million, the World Council of Churches representing 590 million people in 150 countries have divested, 30 cities in the USA, Stanford is dropping coal holdings from its 18 billion endowment funds. (C’mon Harvard, you can do it!) Especially love Dogs for Divestment! Meanwhile investments in renewables is the leading edge in the market.

What’s happening is a eco-re-evolution. When we tune into this our life will start changing, inwardly and externally. As the truth is all things are interconnected, the coming years of this energy and consciousness re-evolution will impact us all in destabilizing, challenging and positive ways. So time to put our practice to use as we connect with refuge, community and our own inner spirit and guidance.

Yesterday I observed Flood Wall Street and had the honor of hanging out with David Loy most of the day as we walked with this activist happening. David was not averse to getting arrested (I was not  up for arrest – not right now anyway.) As we became surrounded by police and as the march moved into a “sit down” David and I went for coffee, aware that it was turning into a long day with an inevitable outcome.

Polar Bear gets arrested
Polar Bear gets arrested

As those on the front line aimed for the belly of the beast, our capitalistic-addicted-steriod-crack-pumped-disembodied-bull-market-machine, (commonly called The Stock Market), David and I talked Buddhist fem-eco-activist-evolution. More about that later, meanwhile, here’s David’s talk from the Eco-Dharma conference in August, Tale of Two Icebergs.

David & DaRa (from NY Insight)
David & DaRa (from NY Insight)

I’m going to finish off by reverting once again to my dear friend Gayle Markow and her “bring it home” advise, after the great joy of walking with a million+ people, across the world, for our mother earth.

Today was truly remarkable because of the really Huge numbers of people that did turn out, their enthusiasm, their creativity, their diversity (in the positive extreme), the enormous positive energy of this march that went on an on and on and on, it was fulfilling and hopeful.  And we All have a lot of work to do to save our Home, our planet, our Mother Earth. This magnificent demonstration was the culmination of much planning and organizing, but Only the Beginning of the Serious Journey to be undertaken. May we all go forward shoulder to shoulder. Much love from NYC. 

I echo that – Much love from NYC – what a city! What a week!


Buddhists Rock!

It’s late and it’s been a loooong day – so instead of writing an update myself, I’m going to post on from my dear friend Gayle Markow who will join the Peoples Climate March with us here in New York City tomorrow. Gayle and I have known each other for many years. Our friendship began early 2000 when she became central to our fund raising campaign at San Francisco Insight for Dharmagiri’s HIV/Aids community outreach work in South Africa.


Now many years later we shared the journey on the Climate Train and today’s events which Gayle records here. This was at at New York Insight. There were about 200 people from a diversity of geographical backgrounds, as well as New Yorkers, meeting to “Prepare the Heart to March.” In the evening we attended a symposium of climate leaders at New York Society of Ethical Culture. Over to Gayle.

I got up, got dressed and hailed a taxi for Insight New York down on 27th Street. Turned out to be the MOST awesome 3 hour event. The two nuns (Ayya Santussika and Santacitta Bhikkhunis) who were on the train with us, Thanissara, Bikkhu Bodhi, Wes Nisker, David Loy, and some other brilliant speakers. It was Mega-awesome!!! A major event unto itself!  

At NY Insight, I “scored” possibly the last available ticket for Bill McKibben’s talk tonight. I never heard him before, or read him, but people spoke highly and I was curious. He was awesome. Then other speakers who were also awesome. Mary Robinson, first woman President of Ireland, and now UN Special Envoy for Climate Change (previously UN High Commissioner for Human Rights). There was Sean Sweeney, founder and co-director of the Global Labor Institute, etc etc… Other speakers All wonderful too. Too numerous to name here right now. Sweeney said that ALL NY area Unions have endorsed the People’s Climate March. Bill McKibben said there will be more than 2700 marches  and events going on around the world (150+ countries) this weekend in Solidarity with the Climate March. UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon will also be joining the Climate March. So much more got said, and it was all of intense interest, and the 800 or so people there tonight were electrified. The energy was palpable.

The Climate March is gonna be huge. Seriously. Huge. And it will transform the movement for change. This is gonna be a wild and interesting ride. Not just the march, which is gonna be Huge. But the next few decades. Because the Earth, and mainly the survivability of our human (and lots of other) species is Seriously at risk, like Never Before. We’re moving rapidly toward what they call the “tipping point” where it will be too late to reverse, to salvage things. It’s already not clear whether we’ve already passed that point, but there seems to be some hope that we haven’t, but that also we don’t have much time, actually hardly any time.

There is a tremendous sense of urgency here. It’s contagious, and at the same time,hopeful. Because people – in large numbers – have gotten serious. I think we might be witnessing the “hundredth monkey effect”. Wow. So, anyway, that was my day. If you can, get out and demonstrate tomorrow, and then be sure to watch the news, and see what kind of news we make here.”

Just to add onto Gayle’s report a mention the presentation at the NY Society of Ethical Culture by Lester Brown who is considered one of the world’s most influential thinkers. He gave a brief preview of his forth coming book which was packed full of truly inspiring data about the fast moving energy transformation from fossil fuels to wind and solar happening all over the world. Countries like Germany and Denmark are leading, and while lagging behind, the USA has the capacity to really fast forward this momentum, given the political will. Brown thinks that we’ll see a significant energy revolution in the next 10 years.

Meanwhile, it’s important to keep the pressure on for change. Here’s more urgency from S.Africa’s Kumi Naidoo – ED of Greenpeace International, spelling it out on the eve of the Peoples Climate March happening all over the world on September 21st.

Rev TK - Japanese American at NY Insight today talking about Nuclear Waste being like having a house with no toilet. (Meaning, we sh#ite in our own home) Time to shift from Nuclear!Back to NY Insight for a moment. The day included speeches on climate, Dharma, and activism, by Ayya Santacitta (we are in climate chaos and there’s nowhere to hide), Ayya Santussika (who reported on the Climate Train, Tar Sands and the Climate Pledge), Bhikkhu Bodhi (who talked of transforming fear into samvega – urgency – and desire into fearless compassion), David Loy (a shift of relationship to body, self and earth), Wes Nisker (the mystery of our cosmological reality, conveyed with humor and lightness), Rev TK (nuclear waste is like having no toilet in your house!), and myself (journey out of denial and reading from The Heart of the Bitter Almond Hedge Sutra.)

Thanks to all who came to share the day and to Kevin Hansen for doing this video of what he called the “new anthem” of the Climate Movement – You heard it here ppl – at our New York Insight event which, as said by Gayle, was AWESOME!